From Schmidt Ocean Institute: “Improving the Odds”

From Schmidt Ocean Institute


Overnight, the ‘star sieve’ returned several hundred grams of rocky material with characteristics similar to what we are looking for in meteorites – black-colored rocks with a smooth exterior surface. But when ALL of the samples from multiple sites look that way, you have either hit the jackpot or something else is going on.


Most scientific investigations start with observation, which when coupled with knowledge, experience, and standardized methods, allow us to draw conclusions about what we are observing. The hard part is to not allow expectation to cloud what we observe in order to achieve an expectation.

`Working in the seafloor mud, we discovered that tidal current, fish and the mucknificence add a unique twist to what is ultimately the most complex treasure hunt ever attempted. Tides either work for or against seeing the seafloor and sifting mud. The light that we need to see the sea floor draw krill, herring and rockfish that challenge our observations. Linda Welzenbach Fries

Close visual examination revealed that the copious bounty of dark rocks are from a local source, which is the disappointing but unsurprising answer. But after a couple days of peering through clouds of mucknificence, finding rocks that look like meteorites requires a stalwart commitment to objective observation, to persistence, and to remaining upbeat in the face of possibly not finding the prize we are seeking.

The top screens show SuBastian’s planned path to attempt to cover 9,000 square meters. Almost half way through the systematic search, the team found a feature that looked similar to an impact crater, for which they employed the ‘star sieve’ and suction sampler. Linda Welzenbach Fries

A Change in Tactics

With just a few hours left and much ground left to cover, the scientists and ROV pilots devise a new strategy. The R/V Falkor sets a course back to the area where the largest meteorites may have landed.

Schmidt Ocean Institute RV Falkor

The plan is to systematically “mow-the-lawn,” looking for impact features or large rocks begging to be found.

So finding lots of rocks that look like meteorites must be put into perspective, not only allowing us to better recognize when we do find one, but to provide the opportunity to tell a different if equally compelling story. One of those stories may be about the history of the seafloor, but for the Seeking Space Rocks, team, this search and the non-meteorite materials we recover may help others to find ways of identifying life on another planet!

Dr. Betsy Pugel and Dr. Marc Fries discuss which samples will be set aside for extraterrestrial biosignature studies. Linda Welzenbach Fries

The Seeking Space Rocks science team includes not only NASA scientists who study the origin and history of the solar system from meteorites, and NOAA’s research coordinator from Olympic Coast National Marine Sanctuary, but other scientists who were interested in the associated interaction of the extraterrestrial materials with life on earth. Scientists from the Laboratory of Agnostic Biosignatures are developing tools and techniques that will allow them to detect life beyond earth.

As the day comes to a close, the samples are packed up for their journey to laboratories around the country. There may still be, among these treasures from the sea, a meteorite or two. All of the samples will journey yet further to help us better understand worlds beyond our own.

Dr. Betsy Pugel stores samples of seafloor sediment and water with will be used to test methods and approaches for identifying life on other planets. Student intern Elisa and artist in residence Abrian Curington identify biological samples such as coal and trees. Linda Welzenbach Fries

See the full article here .


Please help promote STEM in your local schools.

Stem Education Coalition

Our Vision
The world’s oceans understood through technological advancement, intelligent observation, and open sharing of information.

Schmidt Ocean Institute RV Falkor

Schmidt Ocean Institute ROV Subastian

Schmidt Ocean Institute is a 501(c)(3) private non-profit operating foundation established in March 2009 to advance oceanographic research, discovery, and knowledge, and catalyze sharing of information about the oceans.

Since the Earth’s oceans are a critically endangered and least understood part of the environment, the Institute dedicates its efforts to their comprehensive understanding across intentionally broad scope of research objectives.

Eric and Wendy Schmidt established Schmidt Ocean Institute in 2009 as a seagoing research facility operator, to support oceanographic research and technology development focusing on accelerating the pace in ocean sciences with operational, technological, and informational innovations. The Institute is devoted to the inspirational vision of our Founders that the advancement of technology and open sharing of information will remain crucial to expanding the understanding of the world’s oceans.