From Ethan Siegel: “Ask Ethan: When Were Dark Matter And Dark Energy Created?”

From Ethan Siegel
9.8.18

1
Our entire cosmic history is theoretically well-understood, but only qualitatively. It’s by observationally confirming and revealing various stages in our Universe’s past that must have occurred, like when the first stars and galaxies formed, that we can truly come to understand our cosmos. The temporal origin of dark matter and dark energy have constraints, but an exact time-of-origin is unknown. (NICOLE RAGER FULLER / NATIONAL SCIENCE FOUNDATION)

They make up 95% of our Universe today, but they weren’t always so important.

One of the most puzzling mysteries about the Universe is simply, “where is everything?” All that we can see, find, or interact with is made up of particles from the Standard Model, including photons, neutrinos, electrons, and the quarks and gluons which comprise the building blocks of our atoms. Yet when we look out at the cosmic ocean, we find that all of this makes up just under 5% of the total energy in the Universe; the rest is unseen. We call the missing components dark energy (68%) and dark matter (27%), but we don’t know what they are. Do we even know when they came into existence? That’s what Alon David wants to know, asking:

“Today [normal matter] is only 4.9% while Dark Matter and Dark Energy takes the rest. Where did they come from?”

Let’s find out.

2
From the end of inflation and the start of the hot Big Bang, we can trace out our cosmic history. Dark matter and dark energy are required ingredients today, but when they originated is not yet decided. (E. SIEGEL, WITH IMAGES DERIVED FROM ESA/PLANCK AND THE DOE/NASA/ NSF INTERAGENCY TASK FORCE ON CMB RESEARCH)

CMB per ESA/Planck

ESA/Planck 2009 to 2013

There’s so much that we don’t know about dark matter and dark energy, but there are a great many things that we can definitively say about them. We’ve observed that dark energy affects the expansion of the Universe, only becoming prominent and detectable about 6-to-9 billion years ago. It appears to be the same in all directions; it appears to have a constant energy density throughout time; it appears to not clump or cluster or anti-cluster with matter, indicating it’s uniform throughout space. When we look at how the Universe expands, dark energy is absolutely required, with approximately 68% of the total energy of the Universe presently existing in the form of dark energy.

3
The different possible fates of the Universe, with our actual, accelerating fate shown at the right. After enough time goes by, the acceleration will leave every bound galactic or supergalactic structure completely isolated in the Universe, as all the other structures accelerate irrevocably away. We can only look to the past to infer dark energy’s presence. (NASA & ESA)

Dark matter, on the other hand, has shown its effects for the entire 13.8 billion year history of our Universe.

Dark matter cosmic web and the large-scale structure it forms The Millenium Simulation, V. Springel et al

Caterpillar Project A Milky-Way-size dark-matter halo and its subhalos circled, an enormous suite of simulations . Griffen et al. 2016

The great cosmic web of structure, from the earliest times to the present day, requires that dark matter exist in about five times the abundance of normal matter. Dark matter does clump and cluster, and its effects can be seen in the formation of the earliest quasars, galaxies, and clouds of gas. Even prior to that, dark matter’s gravitational effects show up in the earliest light from the Universe: the cosmic microwave background [CMB}, or the leftover glow from the Big Bang. The pattern of imperfections requires that the Universe be made of about 27% dark matter, in comparison to only 5% normal matter. Without it, all that we observe would be impossible to explain.

But does this necessarily mean that dark matter and dark energy were created back at the moment of the Big Bang? Or are there other possibilities? The difficult thing about the Universe is that we can only see the parts of it that are accessible to us today. When an effect is too small to be seen — such as when other effects are more important — we can only draw inferences, not solid conclusions.

This is particularly problematic for dark energy. As the Universe expands, it dilutes; the volume increases while the total number of particles within it stays the same. The matter density (both normal and dark) goes down; the radiation density goes down even faster (since the number of particles not only drops, but the energy-per-photon drops due to redshifting); but the dark energy density remains constant.

4
While matter and radiation become less dense as the Universe expands owing to its increasing volume, dark energy is a form of energy inherent to space itself. As new space gets created in the expanding Universe, the dark energy density remains constant. (E. SIEGEL / BEYOND THE GALAXY)

Our Universe may be dark energy-dominated today, but this is a relatively recent happenstance. In the past, the Universe was smaller and denser, meaning the matter (and radiation) densities were much higher. About 6 billion years ago, the matter and dark energy densities were equal; about 9 billion years ago, the dark energy density is low enough that its effects on the Universe’s expansion rate were not noticeable. The farther we extrapolate back in time (or size/scale of the Universe), the more difficult it becomes to see and measure dark energy’s effects.

5
The blue “shading” represent the possible uncertainties in how the dark energy density was/will be different in the past and future. The data points to a true cosmological “constant,” but other possibilities are still allowed. As matter becomes less and less important, dark energy becomes the only term that matters. The earlier stages, however, make it much more difficult to detect the less important dark energy. (QUANTUM STORIES)

To the best of our ability, it appears that dark energy has an absolutely constant energy density. We can use the data we have to constrain the dark energy equation of state, which we parameterize by a quantity known as w. If dark energy is exactly a cosmological constant, then w = -1, exactly, and does not change over time. We have used the full suite of cosmological data we have — from large-scale structure, from the cosmic microwave background, from objects at great cosmic distances — to constrain w as best as possible. The most stringent constraints come from baryon acoustic oscillations, and tell us that w = -1.00 ± 0.08, with future observatories like LSST and WFIRST poised to get those uncertainties down to about 1%.

LSST


LSST Camera, built at SLAC



LSST telescope, currently under construction on the El Peñón peak at Cerro Pachón Chile, a 2,682-meter-high mountain in Coquimbo Region, in northern Chile, alongside the existing Gemini South and Southern Astrophysical Research Telescopes.

NASA/WFIRST

6
An illustration of how the radiation (red), neutrino (dashed), matter (blue), and dark energy (dotted) densities change over time. In this new model, dark energy would be replaced by the solid black curve, which is heretofore indistinguishable, observationally, from the dark energy we presume. (FIGURE 1 FROM F. SIMPSON ET AL. (2016), VIA ARXIV.ORG/ABS/1607.02515)

This doesn’t necessarily mean that dark energy has always existed with a constant energy density, however. It could change over time, so long as it changes within the observational constraints. There could be a connection between dark energy and the initial, pre-Big Bang expansion of the Universe known as cosmic inflation, which is the idea behind quintessence fields. Or dark energy could be an effect which didn’t exist in the earliest stages of the Universe, and only manifested itself at late times.

Inflation

4
Alan Guth, from Highland Park High School and M.I.T., who first proposed cosmic inflation

HPHS Owls

Lambda-Cold Dark Matter, Accelerated Expansion of the Universe, Big Bang-Inflation (timeline of the universe) Date 2010 Credit: Alex MittelmannColdcreation

Alan Guth’s notes:
5

We have no evidence that speaks one way or the other on dark energy’s presence or absence for the first 4 billion years or so of the Universe’s history. We have good reasons to presume it hasn’t changed, but not the observational certainty to back it up.

7
The largest-scale observations in the Universe, from the cosmic microwave background to the cosmic web to galaxy clusters to individual galaxies, all require dark matter to explain what we observe. The large scale structure requires it, but the seeds of that structure, from the Cosmic Microwave Background, require it too.(CHRIS BLAKE AND SAM MOORFIELD)

Dark matter, on the other hand, must have existed from very early times. The pattern of fluctuations we see in the CMB is the earliest evidence we have for dark matter in our Universe, dating from approximately 380,000 years after the Big Bang.

National Science Foundation (NASA, JPL, Keck Foundation, Moore Foundation, related) — Funded BICEP2 Program; modifications by E. Siegel.

Yet already imprinted in the pattern of peaks-and-valleys in the angular scale fluctuations is overwhelming evidence for dark matter, in that critical 5-to-1 ratio with normal matter. Dark matter has not only been providing the seeds of structure, which causes more and more dark matter to fall into the overdense regions (and be lost from the underdense regions), but has been doing so since the earliest stages in the Universe.

Dark Matter Research

Universe map Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey

Scientists studying the cosmic microwave background hope to learn about more than just how the universe grew—it could also offer insight into dark matter, dark energy and the mass of the neutrino.

Dark matter cosmic web and the large-scale structure it forms The Millenium Simulation, V. Springel et al

Dark Matter Particle Explorer China

DEAP Dark Matter detector, The DEAP-3600, suspended in the SNOLAB deep in Sudbury’s Creighton Mine

LUX Dark matter Experiment at SURF, Lead, SD, USA

ADMX Axion Dark Matter Experiment, U Uashington

Yet already imprinted in the pattern of peaks-and-valleys in the angular scale fluctuations is overwhelming evidence for dark matter, in that critical 5-to-1 ratio with normal matter. Dark matter has not only been providing the seeds of structure, which causes more and more dark matter to fall into the overdense regions (and be lost from the underdense regions), but has been doing so since the earliest stages in the Universe.

8
The relative heights and positions of these acoustic peaks, derived from the data in the Cosmic Microwave Background, are definitively consistent with a Universe made of 68% dark energy, 27% dark matter, and 5% normal matter. Deviations are tightly constrained. (PLANCK 2015 RESULTS. XX. CONSTRAINTS ON INFLATION — PLANCK COLLABORATION (ADE, P.A.R. ET AL.) ARXIV:1502.02114)

This doesn’t necessarily mean, however, that dark matter was present at the instant of the hot Big Bang, though. Dark matter could have been created from the very moment inflation ended; it could have been created from high-energy interactions that took place immediate afterwards; it could have arisen from high-energy particles up at the GUT scale; it could have arisen from a broken symmetry (such as a Peccei-Quinn-like symmetry) slightly later; it could have come about from right-handed Dirac neutrinos when they gained ultra-heavy masses from a cosmic see-saw mechanism; they could have remained massless until the electroweak symmetry broke, which could be connected to dark matter.

9
An illustration of clustering patterns due to Baryon Acoustic Oscillations, where the likelihood of finding a galaxy at a certain distance from any other galaxy is governed by the relationship between dark matter and normal matter. As the Universe expands, this characteristic distance expands as well, allowing us to measure the Hubble constant, the dark matter density, and even the scalar spectral index. The results agree with the CMB data, and a Universe made up of 27% dark matter, as opposed to 5% normal matter. (ZOSIA ROSTOMIAN)

Without knowing exactly what dark matter is — including whether or not it’s a particle at all — we cannot state with any certainty exactly when it may have arisen. But from the measurements of the large-scale structure of the Universe, including the signatures imprinted in the earliest picture of all, we can be absolutely certain that dark matter arose in the very early stages of the Big Bang, and possibly at the very beginning of it all. Dark energy may have been around the whole time, or it may have only emerged much later; there is substantial exploration of the idea that only when complex structure forms, dark energy arises and becomes important in the Universe.

11
The relative importance of dark matter, dark energy, normal matter, and neutrinos and radiation are illustrated here. While dark energy dominates today, it was negligible early on. Dark matter has been largely important for extremely long cosmic times, and we can see its signatures in even the Universe’s earliest signals. (E. SIEGEL)

Part of the great challenge for modern cosmology is to uncover the nature of these missing components of the Universe. If we can do exactly that, we’ll begin to understand when and how dark matter and dark energy arose. What we can say for certain is that, in the very early stages, radiation was the dominant component of the Universe, with tiny amounts of normal matter always present. Dark matter may have arisen at the very beginning, or it may have arisen slightly later, but still very early on. Dark energy is presently thought to have always been there, but only became important and detectable when the Universe was already billions of years old. Determining the rest is a task for our scientific future.

five-ways-keep-your-child-safe-school-shootings

five-ways-keep-your-child-safe-school-shootings

Please help promote STEM in your local schools.

Stem Education Coalition

See the full article here .

“Starts With A Bang! is a blog/video blog about cosmology, physics, astronomy, and anything else I find interesting enough to write about. I am a firm believer that the highest good in life is learning, and the greatest evil is willful ignorance. The goal of everything on this site is to help inform you about our world, how we came to be here, and to understand how it all works. As I write these pages for you, I hope to not only explain to you what we know, think, and believe, but how we know it, and why we draw the conclusions we do. It is my hope that you find this interesting, informative, and accessible,” says Ethan