From Ethan Siegel: “How Can We Tell If A Space Rock Came From Outside Our Solar System?”

Ethan Siegel
Nov 7, 2017 [Where has this been?]

1
A/2017 U1 is most likely of interstellar origin. Approaching from above, it was closest to the Sun on Sept. 9. Traveling at 27 miles per second (44 kilometers per second), the comet is headed away from the Earth and Sun on its way out of the solar system. Image credit: NASA / JPL — Caltech.

The discovery of the first-ever asteroid to arrive from interstellar space is full of lessons for us all.

On October 19th, astronomers discovered an object unlike any other we’d seen before: a massive point of light hurtling through the inner Solar System.

2
Interstellar Visitor’s Path Through The Solar System
This schematic diagram of our solar system shows the dramatic path of A/2017 U1 (dashed line) as it crossed the plane of the planets (known as the ecliptic), and then turned and headed back out. The inset shows the object’s path through the inner solar system, with the short solid segment showing the small two-week-long portion of the path during which the object can be observed by large telescopes. For comparison, the highly elongated orbit of a comet, which is part of our solar system, is also depicted.
Credit: Brooks Bays / SOEST Publication Services / UH Institute for Astronomy

Sure, that might sound like any old asteroid or comet that just happens to pass close to the Sun, but this one was special. Unlike all the others we’ve ever seen, which came from the asteroid belt, the Kuiper belt, or even far out from the Oort cloud, this one was completely different.

Kuiper Belt. Minor Planet Center

Oort Cloud NASA

In fact, astronomers concluded, it came from outside the Solar System entirely. It’s one thing to be told that this is the case, but it’s quite another to understand how we know it must be so. Let’s find out!

3
Comet McNaught, as imaged in 2006 from Victoria, Australia. The dust tail is white and diffuse (and curved), while the ion tail is thin, narrow, blue, and points directly away from the Sun. Image credit: Soerfm / Wikimedia Commons.

When an object passes close to the Sun, that’s the way to tell whether it’s asteroid-like or comet-like. If you develop a large tail, you likely formed in the outer Solar System, and are full of ices and other volatiles. The whole reason comets have two tails — a blue, straight one and a white, curved one — is because of these volatiles, where the straight one is due to ions and the curved one is due to dust. But asteroids are much lower in volatiles, and tend to produce tails only for short amounts of time (for a few passes only), after which you’re just left with a solid core.

When we observed this suspicious object with the Pan-STARRS telescope, famed for its rapid coverage of nearly the entire sky, what we saw indicated an object that was close by, modestly reflective, and completely without a tail or coma.


Pann-STARS telescope, U Hawaii, Mauna Kea, Hawaii, USA, 4,207 m (13,802 ft) above sea level

It was entirely asteroid-like in nature, despite being so close by, in the inner Solar System. This definitely told us it was asteroidal in nature, or — at the very least — all that remained of it was a solid, non-volatile core.

4
The asteroid-like object, now known as A/2017 U1, likely originated from beyond the Solar System. Image credit: Paulo Holvorcem & Michael Schwartz, Tenagra Observatories.

3
Tenagra Observatories, Rio Rico, Santa Cruz County, AZ, USA

But when we examined its orbital properties, a real shock came. First off, it’s highly inclined to the plane of the Solar System, something that normally only occurs for object originating from the Oort cloud or the outer Kuiper belt. An asteroid like this is virtually unheard of. Second off, it was moving fast; far too fast to have been caused by conventional means. Even if you began with this object an infinite distance away and let the full gravitational effects of the Solar System pull it in, it wouldn’t be moving this quickly. The only way to get an object moving at these tremendous speeds is with a gravitational encounter with a very massive planet: a gas giant.

But that’s where the third surprise comes in. If you trace back its orbital path, there’s no way it could have occurred that way. None of the planets encountered it in the past; it’s completely gravitationally unbound.

You can imagine that there are massive objects out there in the outer Solar System, such as in the distant Oort cloud. You can imagine that, perhaps, ideas like Planet Nine are not only valid, but that there are many such massive objects. Yet even if that’s the case, they can’t explain this object. Gravitational encounters with even massive worlds could impart speeds of up to 1,000 meters/second to it, as recent research has shown. Yet from observations of A/2017 U1, we know it came into our Solar System at speed in excess of 20,000 meters/second. There’s no way it came from the asteroid belt, the Kuiper belt, or even the Oort cloud.

4
A logarithmic view of our Solar System, extending out all the way to the next-nearest stars, shows the extend of the asteroid belt Kuiper belt, and Oort cloud. Yet all the properties of A/2017 U1 point to an extra-solar origin. Image credit: NASA / public domain.

The only option left, then, is that it came from another Solar System! This isn’t entirely surprising, since we live in a galaxy filled with hundreds of billions of stars, and we know that asteroids and comets both get ejected from our own Solar System quite routinely, owing to gravitational interactions. Interstellar space must be filled with such minor planets, with this one only a few hundred meters across. With its:

incredibly high eccentricity of ~1.2, versus a maximum of around 1.002 for objects originating within our Solar System,
incredibly high speed-at-infinity of ~20,000+ meters/second, versus a maximum of around 1,000 meters/second for those originating here,
and its lack of encounters with massive objects (like Jupiter) capable of accelerating it to such high speeds,

the conclusion is inescapable; this object is from beyond our Solar System.

5
The nominal trajectory of interstellar asteroid A/2017 U1, as computed based on the observations of October 19, 2017 and thereafter. Image credit: Tony873004 of Wikimedia Commons.

So what does that all mean? It means that, for the first time, we’ve discovered and verified an object from outside our Solar System coming to visit. It means we have confirmation that even if we solve the problem of planetary protection from asteroids and comets within our Solar System, we’ll have these outsiders to contend with. And it means that we’ve demonstrated that we have the capabilities to find and detect these alien visitors. According to Paul Chodas, the manager of the Center for Near Earth Object Studies (CNEOS):

“We have been waiting for this day for decades. It’s long been theorized that such objects exist — asteroids or comets moving around between the stars and occasionally passing through our solar system — but this is the first such detection. So far, everything indicates this is likely an interstellar object.”

If you’re moving too fast and you didn’t encounter any planets on your way in, we can tell that you’re not from around here. We fully expect its density and physical properties to be different from asteroids in our own Solar System as well. Perhaps, by time we detect the next such interloper, we’ll be ready to find out!

See the full article here .

Please help promote STEM in your local schools.

STEM Icon

Stem Education Coalition

“Starts With A Bang! is a blog/video blog about cosmology, physics, astronomy, and anything else I find interesting enough to write about. I am a firm believer that the highest good in life is learning, and the greatest evil is willful ignorance. The goal of everything on this site is to help inform you about our world, how we came to be here, and to understand how it all works. As I write these pages for you, I hope to not only explain to you what we know, think, and believe, but how we know it, and why we draw the conclusions we do. It is my hope that you find this interesting, informative, and accessible,” says Ethan