From Science Node: “NOAA shops for new weather modeling system”

Science Node bloc
Science Node

09 Aug, 2016
Lance Farrell

Looking to improve elements of their forecasting framework, NOAA has announced the winning system to power their weather forecasts.

In 2012 Hurricane Sandy came ashore in New England. Most American weather models predicted it would turn away from the mainland and spend its energy over the sea. European models, however, correctly identified the threat and predicted a westward track for the storm.

Forecasting champ. The FV3 dynamical core won out over six competitors. FV3 improves representation of small-scale weather features such as hurricanes while maintaining the quality of large-scale global circulation. Courtesy NOAA

So what’s the big deal? Forecasts are frequently wrong, right?

“If a high impact event is being forecast, emergency management personnel need to issue alerts in a timely fashion and begin mobilizing resources to deal with the aftermath,” says Rusty Benson of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).

In the case of Hurricane Sandy, the aftermath amounted to 233 lives lost, and $75 billion worth of property damage.

Stung by the missed forecast, NOAA looked to upgrade many elements of their modeling framework, and convened a dynamical core testing group (DTG). This panel of experts evaluated the suitability and readiness of competing dynamical cores, a key component of the forecast system.

“With our current operational dynamical core, it is difficult to represent the movement of clouds, snow, hail and wind at fine scales in an efficient or accurate manner, nor can it be easily upgraded to support the resolutions necessary to capture these aspects of weather systems,” says Benson.

Testing the limits

Testing and developing competing cores calls for strong computational power, so candidates allocated time on Edison at the National Energy Research Scientific Computing Center (NERSC), Stampede at the Texas Advanced Computing Center (TACC), and Pleiades at NASA.

LBL NERSC Cray XC30 Edison supercomputer
LBL NERSC Cray XC30 Edison supercomputer

Dell Poweredge U Texas Austin Stampede Supercomputer. Texas Advanced Computer Center 9.6 PF
Dell Poweredge U Texas Austin Stampede Supercomputer. Texas Advanced Computer Center 9.6 PF

NASA SGI Advanced Supercomputing Center Pleiades Supercomputer
NASA SGI Advanced Supercomputing Center Pleiades Supercomputer

Candidates submitted their completed models, and in spring of 2015, NOAA began tests on Edison comparing performance and scalability of the dynamical cores.

The performance benchmark measured the number of computer processors required to simulate two hours of weather in 21.25 seconds. The scalability metric considered a model’s efficiency as complexity was added to input data.

Of the six original entrants, the choice was narrowed to two: The Model for Prediction Across Scales (MPAS) developed by the National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR), and the Finite-Volume on a Cubed-Sphere (FV3), from NOAA’s Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory (GFDL).

In April 2016, NOAA looked to the Cori system at NERSC to break the tie. The second evaluation undertaken by the DTG looked at ten different criteria. Perhaps most important was isolating and gauging the impact of each dynamical core by using identical physics, Global Forecasting System (GFS) physics, and initial conditions.

“FV3 was the clear winner over MPAS in real-data forecast tests, computational performance, and in the presence of data assimilation,” says Benson. “In many cases FV3 equaled or bested our current operational GFS.”


FV3 will enable American forecasters to model several weather events at different scales simultaneously, with scales projected as fine as one km. The new model should allow meteorologists to predict weather more accurately beyond eight days.


NOAA expects FV3 to run at fine enough resolutions that it can represent individual clouds and yet still be efficient enough for global weather simulations.

NOAA also expects a significant improvement in forecasting hurricane track and intensity and expects to predict extreme weather events like Hurricane Sandy up to a month in advance.

“We are poised to develop and run a more accurate and reliable global model that is used as a basis for all weather forecasts in the US,” concludes NOAA director Louis W. Uccellini. “We are collaborating with the best model developers around the world to ensure the GFS has the most recent advances in weather prediction modeling.”

See the full article here .

Please help promote STEM in your local schools.

Stem Education Coalition

Science Node is an international weekly online publication that covers distributed computing and the research it enables.

“We report on all aspects of distributed computing technology, such as grids and clouds. We also regularly feature articles on distributed computing-enabled research in a large variety of disciplines, including physics, biology, sociology, earth sciences, archaeology, medicine, disaster management, crime, and art. (Note that we do not cover stories that are purely about commercial technology.)

In its current incarnation, Science Node is also an online destination where you can host a profile and blog, and find and disseminate announcements and information about events, deadlines, and jobs. In the near future it will also be a place where you can network with colleagues.

You can read Science Node via our homepage, RSS, or email. For the complete iSGTW experience, sign up for an account or log in with OpenID and manage your email subscription from your account preferences. If you do not wish to access the website’s features, you can just subscribe to the weekly email.”