From LC Newsline: “Superconducting cavities are a ‘hot’ topic”

Linear Collider Collaboration header
Linear Collider Collaboration

15 October 2015
Ricarda Laasch

3
A panel discussion during SRF15. Image: Sebastian Aderhold

Superconducting cavities are an important part of the design for many international accelerator projects. These particle-accelerating structures are used for many different accelerators from those that produce brilliant light for investigating the microcosm of atoms and molecules to those that let elementary particles collide with each other to understand the beginning of the universe.

LHC 15-m cryodipole
LHC 15-m cryodipole

The ILC is also designed for SRF technology.

FNAL SRF
FNAL SRF Cavity

Roughly 16 000 cavities are needed to accelerate electrons and positrons to high energies to study not only the Higgs boson but also other fundamental mechanisms of our cosmos. “I am sure there will be quite a lot of relevant results and discussions relevant for the ILC this year,” said Nick Walker, Global Coordinator for ILC Accelerator Design & Integration based at the German lab DESY, just before the conference.

Right now the field of SRF cavities is as active as it has ever been, not only because of the many accelerator projects around the world which have very high demands on the performance of the difference cavities, but also because the step from ‘home made’ cavities to actual ready-to-use industrial mass-produced cavities is happening right now. In the field of cavities the scientists have always worked closely with industrial partners to build the basic structures but the most important steps have always been done ‘in house’ – at the laboratories by the scientists. These steps have now been transferred to different companies with support of many laboratories to mass-produce cavities in an off-the-shelf fashion.

This transition within the field of cavities clearly reflects itself in the schedule of the conference. In the first two days many overview talks concerning important accelerator projects were given. Status Quo and further steps of the projects were introduced and discussed. Questions concerning design goals and used technologies were always part of the discussions. Each project learns from the projects before. The European XFEL – the first project to use mass produced ready-to-go cavities – is nearly at the end of the cavity production phase and everyone wants to see how the performance and the quality have developed along the production. With two companies producing a total of 800 cavities the statistical analysis of the cavity and the accelerator modules performance was important to many attendees. “It was the first time we have ever done this and we were worried about the performance and how it would work out,” explains Detlef Reschke, who is responsible for review and analysis of the results at the European XFEL project. “Now the results tell us that worrying was not needed.” This is good news for the ILC since the European XFEL uses a similar cavity design and 800 cavities can give a clear indication of how well the production went. Many posters within the poster session on different afternoons illustrated the steps within this project.

European XFEL Test module
European XFEL test module

Following the European XFEL, the Linac Coherent Light Source II (LCLS-II), at SLAC in the US, is the next big project in line and it goes even a step further. A newly developed method to improve the cavities’ quality factor – which means less heat loss for each cavity – should now go into mass production. This method, which brings nitrogen atoms into the metal surface of the cavity, has been under investigation by many different laboratories. It lowers the resistance of the cavity and therefore its heat losses. A complete explanation for this effect is still under discussion within the community and was also ongoing at the conference, but the effect has been proven stable enough. Using the basic cavity recipe from the European XFEL which is now established at the companies and adding the new steps of nitrogen doping should bring LCLS-II, an extension of the already existing light source at SLAC, to life. “With three labs coordinating the R&D effort for the needed new technique the development of the doping process went fast and smooth, so that we have already been able to transfer this new technique to industry,” said Marc Ross, project manager for LCLS-II and former project manager of the Global Design Effort for the ILC. “And this proves that we can further develop and improve this technology fast enough for the ILC.”

SLAC LCLSII
SLAC LCLS-II

Aside from this leap into mass producing ready-to-go cavities there is still a lot R&D ongoing in the field. The following two days were filled with talks from young researchers and established members of this scientific community to present their newest insights concerning SRF cavities. Magnetic flux trapping and expulsion and improving the cooldown procedures were some of the hot topics at the conference. Extremely low temperatures are needed to make the superconductivity work, therefore the cavities need to be cooled down from room temperature to 2 Kelvin (-271 degrees Celsius). This cooling process can have an effect on the cavity performance and scientists are trying to find the best way to cool the structures to achieve the best possible result.

Hot topics took centre stage after the poster sessions as podium discussions concerning most interesting areas of research in the field right now. Apart from cooldown procedures for cavities, cryomodules and whole accelerators there were discussions about possible new materials and how to retain the performance of the cavities after the assembly into a cryomodules. Both topics are important for the future of the field. Different materials offer different properties which could lower heat losses and improve accelerating power. Different approaches are being made to find a new and possible better material than pure niobium from which cavities for the European XFEL and LCLS-II are made.

The assembly into cryomodules is one important step to get from a cavity towards a fully functioning particle accelerator, and it is not an easy procedure. Cleanliness and accuracy are key to building good modules which preserve the high quality of the cavities. Here CEA Saclay, France, has taken the step to hand this work over to an industrial partner and to prove that these complex cryomodules can be built within a tight schedule and in high numbers for accelerator projects like the ILC. “The modules were built by our industrial partner but we own the infrastructure and all the tooling. So after the production phase of the European XFEL CEA would be ready to build cryomodules for the ILC with the already well trained staff from our industrial partner,” said Olivier Napoly, Deputy Leader of the Accelerator Department at CEA and project leader of the module production for European XFEL at CEA.

The week-long conference had many participants from many countries all over the world and the general progress in the field of SRF cavities was shown. Also many vendors and companies involved in the production of cavities were at the conference as exhibitors as well as participants in the conferences poster sessions to show their techniques and production progress to the community. This close partnership between industry and laboratories is another key for accelerator projects like LCLS-II. “We’ll support the two companies to be able to use the nitrogen doping technique on the cavities for LCLS-II,” said Ari Palczewski, Jefferson Lab staff scientist involved in the knowledge transfer for nitrogen doping towards the companies. For the ILC all these activities are important steps to further improve and qualify this accelerating technology and its production process.

See the full article here .

Please help promote STEM in your local schools.

STEM Icon

Stem Education Coalition

The Linear Collider Collaboration is an organisation that brings the two most likely candidates, the Compact Linear Collider Study (CLIC) and the International Liner Collider (ILC), together under one roof. Headed by former LHC Project Manager Lyn Evans, it strives to coordinate the research and development work that is being done for accelerators and detectors around the world and to take the project linear collider to the next step: a decision that it will be built, and where.

Some 2000 scientists – particle physicists, accelerator physicists, engineers – are involved in the ILC or in CLIC, and often in both projects. They work on state-of-the-art detector technologies, new acceleration techniques, the civil engineering aspect of building a straight tunnel of at least 30 kilometres in length, a reliable cost estimate and many more aspects that projects of this scale require. The Linear Collider Collaboration ensures that synergies between the two friendly competitors are used to the maximum.

Linear Collider Colaboration Banner